Assigning arbitral awards: what’s the custom where you are?

In Operafund Eco-Invest Sicav Plc & Anor v Spain [2025] EWHC 2874 (Comm) (10 November 2025), the English High Court ruled that awards made pursuant to the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID) Convention, or under the Energy Charter Treaty (ECT) are not capable of assignment. The Court of Appeal in Operafund Eco-Invest Sicav Plc & Ors v The Kingdom of Spain [2026] EWCA Civ 1392 has now reached the same conclusion, cementing the view of the English courts.

This decision has important implications for investors in dispute with defaulting states. Having expended considerable time and resources securing awards, investors now face further challenges to their options for enforcing them.

The judgment also highlights the growing disparity of approach between different jurisdictions. It addresses the thorny topic of ‘customary international law’, how national courts identify it, and how it is applied to international treaties. Increasingly, parties to investor-state contracts need to understand not just what the relevant treaty says about enforcement or assignment, but how national courts are likely to interpret it.

What was the background?

Operafund Eco-Invest SICAV Plc and Schwab Holding AG (the claimants) invested in Spanish solar energy plants. They argued their investment decision was based upon representations from Spain on minimum tariffs and incentives for renewable energy projects. Spain, it claimed, subsequently revoked those tariffs and incentives, breaching the terms of the ECT and causing substantial losses. The case forms part of a slew of investor-state disputes in the Spanish renewables sector, following changes to subsidy regimes.

The claimants commenced arbitration in 2015, and obtained an ICISD award in the autumn of 2019 for EUR 29.3 million against Spain, pursuant to Article 26 of the ECT. They successfully registered the award in England in September 2021, but Spain applied to set aside the order on grounds of state immunity.

In January 2024, the claimants assigned (as they thought) their rights and interest in the award to Blasket Renewable Investments LLC. They applied to substitute Blasket as claimant in the proceedings pursuant to CPR 19.2(4)(a). Spain opposed the substitution, arguing that the award was not assignable as a matter of international law.

The case (and purported assignment) is being pursued across multiple jurisdictions, with different national courts coming to different conclusions over whether the ICSID Convention prohibits assignment.

What did the Commercial Court decide?

At first instance, in November 2025, the Commercial Court held that there is no rule of customary international law addressing whether arbitral awards under the ICSID Convention are assignable, and it concluded that they are not capable of assignment. Even if they were, the court ruled that awards concerning claims under the ECT would not be assignable.

What did the Court of Appeal decide?

The Court of Appeal broadly adopted the same approach as the Commercial Court, but dealt more comprehensively with the question of customary international law. It held:

  • customary international law prevents state treaty rights being assigned without state consent, and there is no recognised exception to that position for non-state parties;
  • 54 (2) of the ICSID Convention permits only the original parties to the ICSID award to seek its recognition or enforcement, not an assignee;
  • there is insufficient state practice (a widespread and consistent pattern of conduct) or opinion juris (the belief by states that they are following a practice because they are legally required to do so) to establish a customary international law rule permitting assignment;
  • recent decisions from other jurisdictions permitting assignment do not demonstrate a settled international consensus on the question.

Analysis

Spain argued that, because neither the ICSID Convention nor the ECT expressly prohibits assignment, it must therefore be permitted. The Court of Appeal disagreed. The absence of an express prohibition does not create a positive legal right to substitute a new creditor. To hold otherwise would fundamentally alter a state’s international law obligations. The court’s reasoning is likely to be relevant more broadly to questions of investment treaty law.

The court also concluded that the reference in the ICSID Convention to ‘a party seeking recognition or enforcement’ referred only to the party itself, not any assignee. This interpretation can be contrasted with that of other courts including in the US, Australia and the Netherlands, which have all permitted enforcement by assignees.

Practical implications

This judgment makes it very difficult for a successful party in an arbitration to sell or assign ICSID awards to third parties, at least in this jurisdiction. It may also have an impact internationally.

However, this does not prevent investors from exploring alternative options for funding enforcement. Blasket Renewable Investments LLC (the assignee in this case) was incorporated expressly for the purpose of acquiring investment treaty awards. There are clearly advantages to that approach. Purchasing an award gives the assignee complete control over the litigation, allowing it to direct the proceedings and manage them without further reliance on or communication with the original investor. This has benefits for both parties, permitting investors to ‘monetise’ sovereign awards rather than spend decades managing a distressed asset.

While that route is no longer available (at least in this jurisdiction), it may still be possible for entities such as Blasket to finance enforcement of awards. Various structures may be possible, provided the original award creditor remains as the party to enforcement. It is also worth noting that the Court of Appeal expressly confirmed that this decision does not prevent the assignees of non-ICSID awards from enforcing qualifying awards under the New York Convention (see paragraph 44), provided they are assignable under their relevant applicable law.

Finally, Blasket has sought leave to appeal the decision to the Supreme Court. If permission to appeal is granted, the outcome will be eagerly anticipated by all those interested in investor-state arbitration.

Related expertise