Progress on maternity safety: are Baroness Amos’ recommendations being delivered?

The publication of Baroness Valerie Amos’ final report on maternity and neonatal services in June 2026 was intended to be a catalyst for lasting reform. Following a succession of inquiries at Morecambe Bay, Shrewsbury and Telford, East Kent, and Nottingham, the report reinforced familiar messages: women must be listened to, staffing levels must improve, inequalities must be addressed, and accountability must be strengthened. The critical question now is whether meaningful progress has followed.

There have been some encouraging developments. Maternity Voices Partnerships (MVPs) have expanded patient involvement in service design, giving women and families a greater opportunity to influence local services. National maternity safety programmes have strengthened the investigation of serious incidents and improved the sharing of lessons learned. There is also greater recognition of the disparities in outcomes experienced by Black, Asian and disadvantaged women, with targeted initiatives aimed at reducing those inequalities.

Investment has been directed towards recruiting additional midwives, obstetricians, and neonatal staff, while regulators have increased scrutiny of maternity services. Compared with a decade ago, there is greater transparency around safety concerns and more willingness to acknowledge systemic failings when they occur.

However, progress against Baroness Amos’ priorities has been inconsistent and remains overshadowed by continuing concerns about safety. The Care Quality Commission’s latest assessment, The state of health care and adult social care in England 2025/26, published on 23 October 2026, found that more than two-thirds of maternity services were rated either ‘requires improvement’ or ‘inadequate’ for safety. Strikingly, none of the 51 maternity providers assessed for safety were rated ‘outstanding’. These findings suggest that, despite numerous initiatives, many frontline services continue to struggle to deliver consistently safe care.

One of Baroness Amos’ central recommendations was that women should be listened to and treated as active partners in decisions about their care. Yet recent maternity investigations continue to uncover reports from families who felt their concerns were ignored or dismissed. The repetition of this theme across multiple inquiries indicates that cultural change has not yet been fully achieved.

Workforce pressures also remain a significant barrier to improvement. Staff shortages, rising demand and burnout continue to affect maternity units across England. While recruitment efforts are welcome, many services still operate under sustained pressure, limiting their ability to deliver the continuity of care and personalised support that women need.

The evidence also suggests that attention should remain focused on preventing avoidable harm rather than restricting the rights of those who suffer it. Research by the Association of Personal Injury Lawyers (APIL) found that the high cost of medical negligence compensation largely reflects the continuing occurrence of avoidable injuries. Maternity claims account for a significant proportion of NHS negligence liabilities because the consequences of serious injury to mothers and babies can be lifelong.

This is particularly relevant to proposals for a no-fault compensation scheme. While advocates argue that changing the compensation system would improve safety, APIL’s analysis found little evidence to support that conclusion. Countries with some of the strongest patient safety records, including Ireland, operate compensation systems similar to that of the UK. The lesson is clear: safer maternity care is achieved through better care, not through reducing access to redress.

Viewed against Baroness Amos’ priorities, progress has undoubtedly been made, but it has been too slow and uneven. The persistence of poor safety ratings, workforce shortages and recurring concerns about women’s experiences shows that implementation remains the greatest challenge. The recommendations already exist. What maternity services now need is consistent delivery, effective accountability, and a sustained commitment to ensuring that every woman and baby receives safe, high-quality care.

If you or a loved one has been affected by issues addressed in this article, please contact our maternity care team or complete our online assessment form.

Related expertise