BioBrief - May 2022
Our newsletter for the life sciences sector
Introduction - Dr Lisa Page, Partner

Welcome to the spring edition of BioBrief.
 
We start this edition with an article I wrote recently for OBN Connect magazine which covers the challenges faced by Biotech founders on spin-out and the career change it requires. This is something that I am familiar with as I changed my career from project manager of global clinical trials for IQVIA to being an IP lawyer.
 
Moving on from career changes, the thorny issue of whether Unitary SPCs will become a reality and the European Commission’s potential approach and what this will mean for SPC protection is considered in the next article. 
 
Regulatory issues are likely to be a regular feature in BioBrief as the MHRA carves its own way post Brexit. Our article by Rachel Bradley comparing the EU Clinical Trials Regulation and the MHRA consultation on clinical trials gives an insight into the MHRA proposals. The consultation closed on 14th March but as of this edition, there has been no further information released. We await that update. 
 
Data protection remains a recurring theme and raises issues given the international nature of biotechnology development. This next article provides practical guidance on what needs to be done for international data transfers now that final versions of the new standard form International Data Transfer Agreement (IDTA) and Addendum to the new EU Standard Contractual Clauses (SCC Addendum) came into force as of 21 March 2022.
 
We also provide an overview of a landmark case where, for the first time, a contract between a CRO and a client (IQVIA v Cardiorentis) is analysed in detail by the courts. The importance of clarity in the contractual terms in these contracts is highlighted and we provide some practical advice for negotiating these contracts.
 
Finally, in another first for BioBrief, our last topic is discussed in a video update by partner Duncan Curley and senior associate Amanda Easey who have recently joined the team adding Life Sciences IP litigation expertise to our offering. In this video update, they discuss the recent Apixaban case in the Patents Court that found the patent invalid for lack of plausibility, the first time this has been seen for a small molecule patent. It’s only a 10-minute listen and well worthwhile for its succinct review of this important case, that is likely to be the subject of an appeal. 
 
If you have any questions on any of the subject matter covered here, please do get in touch with any member of our growing team here and we will be happy to advise! 
 
Contact
Dr Lisa Page
Partner
IP, IT and Commercial
Email Lisa
Career changes and challenges for Biotech spin-out founders

There are a myriad of different aspects to setting up and running a new company particularly in the biotech sector. All have to be managed for the company to be successful and in most start-ups, there are only a handful of people to do the work. As an IP and commercial lawyer, I will flag the most important issues to look out for when a new biotech company is entering into legal agreements that relate to IP.
Unitary SPC may become reality 

The European Commission has recently closed a call for evidence on proposals to introduce a single procedure for granting supplementary protection certificates (SPCs) across the European Union (EU), in order to prepare an impact assessment and any necessary legislation.

SPCs extend patent protection for up to five years for specific innovative medicinal and plant protection products. The requirements for an SPC are set out in the SPC regulations for the grant of medicinal or plant protection products. They are available for European patents granted by the European Patent Office (EPO), national patents granted in each member state and, in the near future, unitary patents granted by the EPO.

Read more>>

Contact Amanda Easey or Duncan Curley

Comparing the EU Clinical Trials Regulation and the MHRA consultation on clinical trials

Rachel Bradley, partner and Shaan Mehra and Clemency Pleming, trainee solicitors, explain the key provisions of the new EU Clinical Trials Regulation and considers how these compare with the main proposals in the MHRA’s consultation on the UK clinical trials regime.

Read more>>

Contact Rachel Bradley

UK international data transfers

Following the end of the ICO’s consultation (discussed in our September update), final versions of the new standard form International Data Transfer Agreement (IDTA) and Addendum to the new EU Standard Contractual Clauses (SCC Addendum) have been approved by Parliament and came into force on 21 March 2022.

Read more>>

Contact Katie Gordon

The importance of reviewing clinical trial agreements - Cardiorentis AG v IQVIA Limited

Most life sciences organisations will utilise a CRO (contract research organisation) at some stage of their product development lifecycle, whether for a new drug or a medical device. This ruling shines some light on how contractual documentation and industry standards of practice will be interpreted by the English courts.

Read more>>

Contact Dr Lisa Page

Apixaban case review

Partners Duncan Curley and senior associate Amanda Easey have recently joined the team adding Life Sciences IP litigation expertise to our offering. In this video update, they discuss the recent Apixaban case in the Patents Court that found the patent invalid for lack of plausibility, the first time this has been seen for a small molecule patent.

Click here to watch now

Our latest events with One Nucleus 

Entering into contracts with confidence - 5 July 2022, 08.30am – 10.00am, Cambridge
 
Join us as hosts for the One Nucleus ON Helix Fringe event on ‘Entering into contracts with confidence’ on 5th July from 08.30am – 10am.
 
As part of ON Helix we will be discussing the importance for life sciences businesses that are entering into contracts with suppliers, research organisations and contractors in getting this right at the outset to avoid complications and disruption in the future.
 
Rachel Bradley, partner in our life sciences team, will be presenting a practical guide on entering into contracts with suppliers and contractors with confidence – a must attend event for any life science business – you can secure your place for free by clicking on the link below.
 
 
The race for space – insights in leasing of commercial R&D space - 14 June 2022, 08.30am – 10.00am, Cambridge
 
Join us as we host the One Nucleus Business Intelligence Breakfast on ‘The race for space – insights in leasing of commercial R&D space’ on 14th June 2022 from 08.30am – 10am.
 
With availability of lab space at record lows across the UK and demand for space at an all time high, it’s now vital to ensure the terms of your lease are transparent and the implications clearly understood.
 
Our expert real estate team, led by partner Sarah Coates, will be presenting a practical guide for leasing terms for emerging life sciences companies – you can secure your place for free by clicking on the link below.
 
Join us at the OBN BioThirstday – 30 June 2022, 6pm, The Lost and Found, Birmingham

Penningtons Manches Cooper are sponsoring the next OBN BioThirstday which will be held on 30 June 2022 from 6pm at The Lost and Found in Birmingham. BioThirstdays are a great way to establish connections and raise your profile with like-minded colleagues from across the life sciences industry. It’s free to attend, with a drink on arrival and nibbles during the evening also included.

Click here to register 

Contacts
Chris Shelley
Partner
IP, IT and Commercial
Email Chris
Rachel Bradley
Partner
IP, IT and Commercial
Email Rachel 
Dr Lisa Page
Partner
IP, IT and Commercial
Email Lisa
Duncan Curley
Partner 
IP, IT and Commercial
Email Duncan
James Went
Partner
Corporate
Email James
Will Axtell
Partner
Corporate 
Email Will
RELATED LINKS
USEFUL RESOURCES
  
Penningtons Manches Cooper LLP is a limited liability partnership registered in England and Wales (No. OC311575). We are authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority. Reference to ‘Partner’ means members, employees and consultants of equal standing. A list of members is available for inspection on request.

The information and material is current at the date of publication and is not intended to constitute legal advice or recommendation. 
You are advised to seek your own legal advice regarding any specific legal issue.
 
Our Privacy Notice may be viewed at 
www.penningtonslaw.com/privacy-policy.